This story is about Mitch, a father who found himself in a puzzling situation involving his sister-in-law, Jane, and his 6-year-old son’s birthday gift. Let’s take a look at what happened.
Jane Is Vocal About LGBTQIA+ Rights
Jane was an active supporter of LGBTQIA+ rights and identified as pansexual, even though she has only dated individuals who appear traditionally male.
She had always been quite vocal about her beliefs. Despite her own relationship choices, she proudly identified as an ally to the LGBT+ community.
Now, onto Mitch’s son. Jane had a unique idea: because Mitch’s son had female best friends, it could signal that he might be transgender or at least non-binary.
Mitch, like Jane, understood that this was a conversation that might be necessary when his son was older.
A Birthday Party Was Looming
However, he firmly believed that at six years old, confusing his son with such matters wouldn’t be helpful. However, this is where the issue first began.
Jane didn’t seem to let the topic rest, repeatedly bringing it up with Mitch’s wife and clarifying her stance.
Mitch explained that Jane was 45 years old and childless, and she dedicated a significant amount of time to these discussions.
As it happened, a birthday party was on the horizon for Mitch’s son.]
She Suggested Their Son Could Wear Her Gift to His Party
Their family didn’t particularly like the idea of unwrapping gifts in front of everyone due to potential discomfort or embarrassment.
However, with her heart in the right place, Jane insisted that the present she brought be opened immediately.
She believed that her gift could be a hit and even suggested that Mitch’s son might consider wearing it to the party!
Mitch and his wife appreciated the gesture but declined, explaining that they would look at it later.
… A Pink Dress and Costume Jewelry
Half an hour later, upon inspecting the gift bag, Mitch found a pink dress and costume jewelry!
Mitch took it upon himself to address the situation with Jane. He expressed gratitude for her gift but firmly declined it, explaining that they didn’t want it for their son.
Jane, though well-meaning, insisted that they let their son see the gift before making a decision. Mitch, however, stood his ground and firmly said no.
He told her that either she takes the gift back herself or they’ll return it themselves. Jane became visibly frustrated and persisted, urging them to at least let their son try on the dress.
They Allow Their Son To Choose His Own Clothes
Mitch remained resolute in his decision and refused her request.
So Jane then took her concerns to Mitch’s wife, hoping for a different response, but his wife’s stance was the same as Mitch’s!
Mitch and his wife firmly stand by their son’s preferences and his expressions, which have never indicated a desire to be a girl or wear dresses.
When they go shopping, they allow their son to choose his clothes, and he has consistently shown no interest in the girls’ section.
Was He Wrong for Rejecting the Dress?
Jane’s reading into the fact that he got along well with girls didn’t necessarily point to anything other than his friendships.
But still, Mitch wanted to know – Was he wrong for rejecting the dress Jane got for his son?
The consensus on Reddit was clear: Mitch was not in the wrong.
Many Redditors agreed that imposing apparent desires onto a child against a parent’s wishes was inappropriate and selfish.
A Peculiar Idea To Push Dresses Onto a 6-Year-Old Boy – She’s Super Weird!
The consensus was that such actions might make the child feel restricted in his friendships with girls, creating unnecessary confusion and pressure.
It was considered a misguided and peculiar idea to push dresses onto a 6-year-old boy, especially when the child’s preferences were clear.
The general sentiment was that projecting these notions onto a 6-year-old was absurd and out of line.
One user said, “Jane is super… SUPER weird for pushing this on a 6-year-old child, and that’s coming from someone who considers themselves an ally. If he had shown some curiosity, maybe… but to just throw it at him because he has girl bffs? I’d cut her off if she can’t respect your boundary.”
But what do you think? Was Mitch too rude when it came to dealing with Jane? Should he have let his son see her gift? Let us know what you think in the comments!
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / fizkes. The people shown in the images are for illustrative purposes only, not the actual people featured in the story.