“Sanctuary Cities” are starting to struggle under the pressure of mass immigration on their welfare systems and communities, and now some Liberal politicians are starting to rethink their stances.
‘Black Trump’ Has a Change in Perspective
In 2020, Shivanthi Sathanandan, a Democratic Party Official, called for the dismantling of the Minneapolis Police Department due to systematic failures in serving the black community.
Fast forward to 2023, and Sathanandan, after being carjacked in front of her children, is thanking Minneapolis police officers and urging the need to “take back our city.”
New York City Mayor Eric Adams was once a staunch advocate of migration but has now become a skeptic, earning him the moniker “black Trump.”
His change of heart is primarily driven by the realization that his city can’t sustain the influx of people availing its services.
In New York, the “sanctuary city” status that once welcomed migrants has been stretched to its limits, with around 110,000 newcomers seeking assistance.
The financial burden is forcing local agencies to make budget cuts of up to 15 percent, potentially reaching a staggering $12 billion in costs over three years.
Destroying New York City
In a recent town hall meeting, Mayor Adams said, “Never in my life have I had a problem that I did not see an ending to,” but “I don’t see an ending to this. This issue will destroy New York City.”
Mayor Adams is now pointing fingers at Joe Biden’s administration for lacking an exit strategy and at Texas Governor Greg Abbott for sending migrants to Democrat-run cities.
While some may argue that this approach is unfair, Abbott’s move to redistribute the burden across various cities has sparked debates on its morality and its effect on other cities across the country.
Chicago, for instance, has taken in around 13,500 migrants at a cost of at least $250 million.
At the same time, Massachusetts declared a state of emergency due to an 80 percent increase in the shelter population.
The Big Apple’s Appeal
New York’s appeal as a destination for migrants lies in its established connections, global city status, and a potent magnet known as the “right-to-shelter” policy, which legally obligates the city to provide housing to those in need.
New York’s generous welfare system has unintentionally encouraged mass migration, and, as seen in San Francisco’s drug policy, such incentives can have unintended consequences.
New York City’s experience demonstrates that a generous welfare system can attract migrants, but the constant influx can render the system financially and politically unsustainable.
This paradox is especially problematic for classic Left-wing objectives. In Chicago, a predominantly Democrat city, residents have voiced concerns about shelters in their neighborhoods.
These concerns stem from the fear that additional competition for already limited resources will increase poverty and crime in an already struggling city.
One resident told the New York Times that the idea of a sanctuary city “is wrong… No one is entitled to anything.”
In response to this situation, many people seem to feel like this is what these sanctuary cities deserve for jumping to extreme policies without fully considering the consequences.
One social media user commented on the situation, “I say nobody helps them, they have to own up to the damage they enabled. Said lawmakers who enabled this should be stripped of their rank and barred from ever serving public office again. Common citizens suffered because of this ego they carried.”
A Second user said, “It is amusing how these liberal cities (mostly non-border states) claim to support adding immigrants and say that they are sanctuary cities until they receive a small surge in immigrants. Then they scream and cry that they can’t handle it. The border states deal with millions of unwelcome immigrants every year and have had no support of Dem politicians; in fact, the Dems have denied that it is an issue.”
This user simply stated, “The Liberals sowed a lot of ideas that, in some cases, took root. Now, they are reaping what they sowed and are finding out it is inedible weeds.”
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Fishman64